The Wrong Date
The painting came from a flea market stall on a Sunday in October, from an old man with thick glasses who sold nothing but framed pictures of women nobody remembered. He said it would bring me luck in love. I did not believe him. I bought it anyway, because the girl in it was beautiful and the price was right and I had not had a date in two years.
She is pale, dressed all in white, with a strange pink crown on her head and her eyes glancing away from whoever looks at her. The old man wrapped it in brown paper and told me to hang it where I would see it every day. I hung it in the hallway, opposite the mirror, and mostly forgot about it. That was my first mistake.
On the night of the date I was running late and checking my hair in the hallway mirror, and in the reflection I saw the painting hanging crooked on the opposite wall. Nothing strange about that. Except the girl in it was grinning. Not the shy, glancing-away face I knew. A grin, wide and pleased, like she had been waiting for me to turn around. I turned. She was the same as always. Shy. Eyes averted. I walked over and straightened the frame with hands that were shaking for no reason I could name. My phone buzzed. The date started in fifteen minutes.
In the car, the seatbelt chime went off. I was already buckled in. I always buckle in before I even turn the key. I sat there listening to it for a few seconds, confused, and then I reached over and hit the release on the passenger buckle, and the chime stopped. The passenger seat was empty. The sensor must be faulty, I told myself. It was the second strange thing that evening, and I counted them the way you count cracks in a windscreen, hoping they stop spreading.
Her name was Lena. She was waiting for me at the restaurant I had picked, and when I saw her I understood for the first time why I had bought a painting from a strange old man. She was beautiful in a way that made the room feel staged, like I had walked onto a set. I waved. I walked toward her. Halfway there my sleeve caught on something and my arm jerked back so hard I nearly fell. I turned, expecting a chair, a table corner, someone's handbag. There was nothing there. Nothing at all. I shrugged it off and kept walking.
We ordered drinks. I had rehearsed topics, little stories, questions that would make her laugh. I was doing fine. And then something cold touched the edge of my neck. I reached up without thinking, to wipe away whatever it was, water from a vent, a drip. My fingers came away dry. The cold stayed. It spread across my neck like a collar being fastened, slow and deliberate, and I could swear it tightened. "Is something wrong?" Lena asked.
"No," I said, too fast. "I thought I felt something. Is it cold in here?" She tilted her head. "A little. Restaurants always are." I nodded and changed the subject and tried to be charming, and all the while the cold kept spreading, down the front of my shirt, across my chest. I had to fight not to shiver. My teeth wanted to chatter. And then, sharp and sudden, a pinch of cold on my skin, like fingernails. I jerked backward mid-sentence and stopped talking.
"What was that?" she asked. "Nothing. A draught, I think. Maybe I am sitting under a vent." "You could put your jacket on." "No, it is fine." It was not fine. The cold had reached my back. I could feel something soft and cold pressing against me between my shoulders, like hands lying flat on my spine, and then the pressure began to move, slow fingers counting their way down, vertebra by vertebra. My hands went numb around the wine glass. I nearly dropped it. Lena was watching me now, really watching, the way you watch someone who might be about to be sick in a nice restaurant.
The food arrived. I picked up my fork with fingers I could barely feel, and under the table something tugged at my jacket. I ignored it. Then my chair moved. Not a slide, not a nudge. It jerked an inch toward the table, as if someone had kicked it from behind. My legs went cold from the knees down, then heavy, then gone entirely, the way your foot goes dead after sitting on it too long, except this was both legs at once, and it was climbing.
"Excuse me," Lena said. "I need the restroom." She stood and walked away, and the moment she was out of sight I bent down and lifted the tablecloth. Under the table, crouched in the dark with her white dress pooled around her like spilled milk, was the girl from the painting. Her face was the same, pale and beautiful, but her eyes were black with red centers, and her mouth was too wide, and she was smiling the grin I had seen in the mirror. Her hands were in long white gloves, and both of them were resting on my knees. That was the cold. That was all of it. I dropped the cloth and tried to stand, but the gloved hands closed around my wrists and dragged me back down with a strength that should not have been possible, and I felt the cold pour into me like water into a drowning man.
That is when I understood. The painting does not bring luck in love. It brings her. The old man had not sold me a charm. He had sold me a door, and I had hung it in my hallway and invited her in, and now she was feeding. Every touch took warmth. Every touch took a little more of me. My breath came out in fog. The tips of my fingers had gone white. Somewhere above the table, in the warm bright restaurant, Lena was washing her hands, and down here in the dark the woman in white was deciding how much of me she wanted to keep.
Lena came back. "Your face is bright red," she said, and grinned a little. "You are kind of a lightweight, are you not?" I tried to tell her. I tried to say the words: there is something under the table, there is something in my hallway, do not come home with me. But my jaw would not open properly, and my tongue was numb, and the cold was in my throat now, sitting there like a stone. What came out was a nod. She laughed. "I have had a bit too much to drink," she said. "I do not know if it is safe for me to drive home. Could you give me a ride to your place?" I nodded again. I could not do anything else.
The drive home was the longest of my life. Lena talked, bright and a little drunk, about the food and the wine and how glad she was that she had said yes. I said nothing. My hands were frozen to the wheel. At a red light I checked the rearview mirror, and in the back seat, sitting where no one had sat, was the girl in white, her pink crown catching the streetlight, her grin wider than any human mouth should go. Lena did not see her. Or she pretended not to.
At home I unlocked the door and Lena stepped into the hallway and stopped. "That is a beautiful painting," she said. It was hanging crooked again. The girl in white was smiling straight at me now, not glancing away at all. And behind her, in the painted dark of the picture, there was a man. He was wearing my jacket. He was pale. His eyes glanced away from the viewer, shy and demure, the way hers used to. I looked at my own reflection in the hallway mirror. My lips were blue. Frost glittered on my collar. And around my neck, tight as a necklace, was a ring of bruises in the shape of ten small fingers.
I tried to tell her to run. I tried to say it with everything I had left. What came out, in a voice that was not quite mine, was: "Would you like to stay?" Lena smiled. "I would love to," she said. And behind her, in the hallway mirror, the girl in the painting winked at me. The old man will sell the painting again tomorrow. He always does. And somewhere in the paint, behind the woman in white, there is room for one more face. Mine is already drying.
Never miss a nightmare
One new horror story in your inbox, every Tuesday and Friday. Plus the free Red Room e-book — three brutal originals, subscribers only. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
One story every Tuesday and Friday — unsubscribe anytime. We store your email only to send you the newsletter. See our Privacy Policy.
Browse more horror
Best horror stories Short scary stories Free scary stories True scary stories Creepypasta stories Best ghost stories Stories to tell in the dark Psychological horror Two-sentence horror